Have compassion, yes. But temper it with reason.
Each day I see those who are not well off. Those who need a helping hand. My heart goes out to many of them.
Especially now, at Christmas, it normal to want to spread compassion and help those he need it and deserve it. Just last month, I assisted a youth group in their project to feed the homeless at a homeless shelter.
I fully support donating time and food in such worthy causes. But I draw the line at giving them money. For example, I often see homeless men on the side of the road with a cardboard sign reading “need a little help, please!” or something similar.
I feel for his plight, but I refuse to reward him not changing his life.
I admit there are many mentally ill among the homeless. I am half-way through a master program to become a counselor. I plan to donate time for those who are homeless and mentally ill. But I still will not give them money.
Am I heartless? Hear me out. First, let’s talk about compassion.
Types of compassion
Most people know what compassion is: feeling bad for others, wanting to ease their burdens. Some of us don’t realize there are two approaches to compassion: feminine compassion and masculine compassion.
Most of us know what feminine compassion is: the desire to help, nurture and care for another. Masculine compassion is a little more harsh. It is also feeling for the other person, and a desire to help. But it also recognizes helping can mean demanding action, or taking action to relieve suffering.
Here is the best example I can give to explain the two types of compassion: I like to watch animal planet and similar type shows. The program I watched not long ago was a documentary on lions. A young lioness was trampled by a herd of animals as it was trying to hunt. It was seriously injured.
The other female lions gathered around the injured one. They nurtured it, stayed close to it and did everything one would expect from the nurturing nature of compassion.
Then the male came over. He too was attentive to the injured lion. But when it became obvious that the injured lioness was seriously injured, the male killed it.
This is a harsh example of feminine and masculine compassion. As difficult as it may be to understand, the male lion’s act was just as loving as the nurturing of the females: he ended the suffering of a friend when it was obvious that friend would not recover.
(For a better explaination of feminine and masculin compassion, read Yin and Yang Compassion.)
Help them. But don’t give them money.
A sign I recently saw entering Grand Junction, Colorado read, “A hand-out is not helping them out.”
When dealing with the homeless, I support donating food, clothing, toys, etc to help them. I have done so myself. But as soon as we start handing them cash, many of them lose incentive to do anything better. It’s operant conditioning at it’s finest: Reinforcing a behavior so it is repeated.
A friend of mine’s son has been homeless for several years. He refuses to get a job. And he’ll tell you, “why should I?” He gets free food, free medical care, donations on the street. On Sunday, he doesn’t have to go to church, church comes to him as missionaries preach and feed him. In most ways, he lives the carefree lifestyle many of us wish for.
We form our own reality
We live the lives we want. That’s the message in The Secret, which I wrote about in Why is The Secret in everything?
We make choices every day. Some of the choices are subconscious ones, but we make them. These choices affect our realities. They become our realities.
I am living the life I chose to live. Even though there are many things about it I am unhappy with, I chose it anyway. Now that I recognize it, I am doing things to make new choices.
It is the same with the homeless.
Have “tempered” compassion. Help them with food, clothing, job training and encouragement. Show them what they need to do to overcome homelessness. Instill in them a vision of prosperity.
But never pay them to be homeless.
(Update: not everyone agrees with this point of view. What do you think? Leave a comment below.)





